We’ve all heard naysayers scoff at the recent gamification trends, but whether it’s Starbucks offering customers virtual badges for visiting retail stores or the most basic Frequent Flyer programs, gamification is growing increasingly more popular as a way to motivate and incite engagement. In fact, website builder, DevHub saw the number of user-completed activities increase from 10 percent to 80 percent after adding gamification elements in August 2010.
That’s why back in July/August 2010 when the 2011 SXSW panel picker process started, I decided to make gamification an integral part of my SXSW Interactive presentation. Don’t get me wrong — I wanted to share information and insight, I just didn’t want to do it by the traditional formula of me talk/you listen. At the same time, there continued to be the ongoing debates (published in blog posts and pontificated at live events) that fall under the category of “the world according to social media experts.” In my mind, the endless debates and questioning of “what makes a social media expert?,” and “what is the ROI of social media?” – amounted to a lot of talk, but not a lot of help.
So I decided on a panel that aggregated all three things — games, industry insight, and my feelings on the overabundance of people calling themselves social media experts. Here is the short write up that captured the spirit of my emotions:
Tired of @#%ing Social Media Experts?
You cannot swing a dead cat without hitting a “social media expert” (that is an expression, I am not suggesting kitty homicide). These “experts” are self anointed, often re-publishing sound bytes. But perhaps the best answers come from practitioners, like you. Join this session to get real answers from your peers on the toughest questions in social media. Format will be a quiz game show where audience volunteers are asked a question. The worst answer will lose their seat. There will be a final round to anoint the “social media expert”. The winner (determined by the audience) will win a valuable prize, in addition to the glory. You will learn real answers to real questions, but perhaps most importantly learn that the real experts getting business results are not necessarily the ones who spend the most time pimping themselves on Twitter. 
So with the comical talents of Sam Decker (CEO Mass Relevance, wearing the Elvis wig and shades), we designed our panel to educate through entertainment. Sam and I used props (wigs, pieces of flare, game show antics, prizes) to help people laugh and not get hostile to the same questions that are often debated online. We let the audience participate and by doing so, we demonstrated that inside each of us there is an “expert.”
To demonstrate the Ant’s Eye View way (we believe in empowering our clients), we included one of Ant’s Eye View’s clients, Rich Yang, Small Business Marketing at VISA, as the game show judge. We felt Rich was uniquely qualified in that both he and VISA often struggle with the same questions. As such, Rich’s role was to listen to contestants and pick the winner (and filter out any BS). And in our estimation, Rich did a wonderful job explaining that every organization is on a Social Engagement Journey and that we should not expect to be a fully engaged enterprise overnight. Rather, organizations should recognize that it’s not just about hiring social media experts; it’s about assessing your brand/company on the journey and then determining how best to proceed from there. Many times this does require hiring a more experienced practitioner, but that’s not always the case. Ultimately, it’s most important for a company to aim towards particular business outcomes.
Which leads me to assessing the outcomes of our 2011 SXSW panel — Sam and I are already thinking about SXSW 2012. If you were at our panel this year, any suggestions for improvements in 2012?
Disclosure: I do not claim to be a social media expert. I am a practioner and a coach that has had the experience to design and operate social media inside the enterprise. My background is marketing, customer service, and corporate communications. I applied social engagement to these business disciplines to create new operating models that included social media.
Special thanks to SMMCast for the summary of our session: Tired of F@#king Social Media Experts?